How A Reluctant Hero Built A World: Letting Characters Make Choices The Writer (Initially) Hates
The deeper I get into this saga, the more I realize how present the characters are in their world. I may be the author, but these are definitely their lives, their homes, and their futures that they’re navigating – very often without my consent.
When you start to write, no one warns you how emotional a story can become. At least, for authors who don’t outline every single detail (no shade to them if it works for them!). Being a discovery writer, where an ‘outline’ can be a one-sentence “this is how the book ends” flexible goalpost, when the flow happens and you’re simply there logging down what the characters are doing on their own, it is often shocking how a scene pans out. Often, I dare say, it is even more shocking for the author than the reader. The reader comes into the story knowing that they have no control over the words and are there for the experience, with the stage already set and the actors knowing their lines by heart. For a discovery writer, well… It’s often a layered blooper reel and trauma center we get to sort through while discovering who these crazy people running amuck in our settings are. And they don’t mind raking up the medical bills.

Agency Versus Boundaries
In The Sourcer Saga, at least for these rough drafts that are still being written (halfway through book 5, start of October, 2026!), the characters are free to run around and be who they are. Writers who are able to do this, where they can relax and watch the events unfold, are employing a very rarely discussed tool that not every writer has access to. It’s called Illusion of Independent Agency (IIA), and it’s something that most people who had an imaginary friend are able to employ. Some skim the surface, writing down what the characters do and comparing it to seeing their work play out like they’re at the movies. Some delve a little deeper and find their characters recoiling from a direction the story is taking, or refusing to ‘get into character’ (creating a writer’s rut), or even demanding compensation from the writer before helping the writer out of said rut. Some authors even go deep, and are able to interview their characters out-of-world or, even, envision them walking into the room the writer is in for a chat – or a fit, depending on their personality and what they’re reacting to.
Now, before some of you go looking up how to recommend a blogger to the psych ward, I recommend doing some research of your own on the topic. For example, a study out of the University of Oregon reported that 92% of fiction writers interviewed admitted to experiencing this phenomenon, mildly or even deeply and intensely. Another survey, by John Foxwell, showed 71% of professional writers claiming their characters grew more autonomous over time, most commonly after the first 30,000 words. Your favorite authors very likely experienced this as well, even those from antiquity.
"A new character has come on the scene (I am sure I did not invent him, I did not even want him, though I like him, but there he came walking into the woods of Ithilien): Faramir, the brother of Boromir - and he is holding up the 'catastrophe' by a lot of stuff about the history of Gondor and Rohan (with some very sound reflections no doubt on martial glory and true glory): but if he goes on much more a lot of him will have to be removed to the appendices..."
Letter 66 of The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien

Characters Exercising Agency
Lance, the protagonist of The Sourcer Saga, is definitely behind the wheel of his scenes. He has encased that wheel into a block of concrete more times than I care to admit, and he does so as a means of strongarming me into going back to earlier manuscripts and figuring out what’s wrong before he’ll settle back into the newer material. Another surprisingly rebellious character in this manner (at least, surprising to me), is a character named Slone, who we meet early in book 1, Desert’s Anomaly, alongside Nahm and Colwin. Slone is the young scholar of the group, and he has told me far too many times, while I am writing a scene for him, how their world works. The topic can range from magic, to religious faith, even global affairs and politics. Lance is very action oriented in how he drives the plot forward, whereas Slone demands a lot of logic and sensibility. Regarding the latter, he stated in passing on an edit for book 1 that a certain region is under sanction by a particular ruler, meaning a place they are presently in is heavily guarded at its exit point. This, quite literally, had my fingers go still on the keyboard, thinking on that, and I proceeded to have a very one-sided argument with him that this cannot be the case, because if it is, then the entire climactic ending, the whole last quarter of the first book, required either heavy editing or a complete re-write. Slone was inflexible on the matter, and I was content with spending a month reworking the book to fit his narrative and world. It improved the work drastically, in the end, and I was rewarded with a catharsis that, into book 5 now, Slone has yet to forgive me for.

Most people hesitate to talk about Illusion of Independent Agency. We’re already quite mad, putting down an imaginary world to paper to share our dreams and ideas with other people, after all, but IIA takes it a step into a place most deem uncomfortable to consider. Personally, I had no idea it was even happening when I was writing. It was simply how I thought, how things came together, and how I explored ideas. Normal. When I learned it had a name, though, the fear of stigma did present itself, worrying about judgment from others. But the creative opportunity told the stigma to be quiet and go sit down in the corner while I eagerly sat down to a fresh document and began interviewing my characters. Funny enough, they were shy at first, but given five minutes to warm up to the idea and letting Lance step forth first to chat had everyone else soon spilling forth, saying what they don’t like about certain scenes, asking for changes, sharing ideas, even considering the overarching plot and how best to arrive at the end. Slone is still orderly and efficient, Lance still flies by the seat of his pants, and each of the characters comes forth now when they feel like it, chatting at me in their voice and wanting to work towards the destination. It’s crazy – kind of literally. And it’s my absolute favorite thing. Farewell, video games and television shows, you served your roles in my life, thank you.
Are there any characters you come across that feel like a unique individual?
© 2026 J. E. Hedden. All rights reserved. The Sourcer Saga and related content.



Comments